Wednesday, July 18, 2007

TV Dinners

I was raised on TV dinners. That's not an indictment of my mother. It was convenient and easy to clean up. Salisbury steak was my favorite. It was a special treat for me, a neat freak. I couldn't stand it when the food on my plate ran together. My dad would always chide me saying something like, "it all ends up in the same place doesn’t it?" But the whole idea of the TV dinner just seemed to fit me.

My TV dinner kept everything neat and tidy in its own space. The meat stayed meat. The gravy stayed out of the cherry surprise. The peas didn’t have cherry sauce all over them. Each compartment held its own wonderful moment. Moving from one compartment to the next allowed my pallet to make the adjustment from one flavor to the next. No mess. Each item in its own place. Simple.

I grew up in church. A very conservative church.

Sunday was for church. We “rested on the Sabbath,” which meant religious activities all day, even though “Sabbath” was technically supposed to be Saturday, but I wasn’t supposed to ask questions. I was not a morning person. We would endure the torture of putting on our dress clothes. My three other siblings and I would fight over the bathroom, the cereal, even the best seat in the van. It was chaos. We fought tooth and nail against this Sunday ritual until the very last moment. But once we exited the vehicle, the time to fight was past. We were “at church.” By exiting the van we had somehow left the compartment of home, and entered the compartment of “church.” This compartment belonged to God. We would sing songs about God. Listen to people read stories about God. Pray to God. And then give our money to God. Then after a couple of the slowest hours I could remember, it was time to leave the God compartment and reenter the home compartment. This, of course is not what I was meant to learn from my foray back and forth “to church.” But for me, growing up in “the real world,” outside of the church walls, there was this real sense that even though I was taught that God was everywhere, we met him primarily at church on Sundays during a semi-private ceremony.

Somehow there was this disconnect in which I lived. I have come to know this disconnect as the sacred versus secular conflict. It’s as if God was different once I left the church building and entered a new compartment. He didn’t seem the same in the other compartments. He always seemed distant; like I had left him behind at “church.” So I went about ordering my life into compartments. There was one for home, one for school, one for work, one for entertainment and so on. It’s as if there were a different set of rules in play for each compartment. For instance, in Sunday school we learned to love your enemies, but then, my enemies were my brothers, and that would never fly in my home compartment.

And I certainly didn’t want God to follow me into the movie theater. That was my entertainment compartment. Religion had nothing to say to me there. And at work and at school, I wanted to be liked and admired so it was easy to follow the crowd and pretend I wasn’t a Christian at all.

And I was allowed to listen to music only if it meant Christian music; which I readily compartmentalized into the church compartment, and readily opened a new music compartment containing Zeppelin, Journey and their friends who were really good and moved me to explore some of the deeper things in life.

It became easy to keep everything in its place, neatly tucked away, ready to switch from one to the next at a moments notice. After all, people in the “real world” could never fit in my church compartment, and the people in my church compartment seemed eager to pretend the “real world” didn’t even exist. It was like a bad episode of the X-files.

Nowadays, I’m trying hard to follow Jesus and actually live the way He calls me to live, instead of just aspiring to be loving and kind and patient, etc… But as I have been struggling through the ramifications of God calling us to be the church instead of just going to church, I find myself trying to come to grips with the compartments I created years ago to deal with the disconnect between what we called “church” and “the real world.” And one of the most difficult things to deal with is the impact this change has on what I do in the “church” compartment. I am learning to practice loving my enemies, and helping people in need, and living wisely, but what do I do about the event we call worship?

Where does it fit? Does it even fit at all?

Jesus once had a conversation with a woman about how worship was to be done. It turns out that the worship wars have been going on a long time. She complained that her and her ancestors worshiped God in a certain way in a certain place, but that the Jewish people claimed that their way of worshiping God was the only right way (sound familiar?). Then Jesus replied, "Believe me, the time is coming when it will no longer matter whether you worship the Father here or in Jerusalem. But the time is coming and is already here when true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and in truth. The Father is looking for anyone who will worship him that way. For God is Spirit, so those who worship him must worship in spirit and in truth (see John 4.”)

Jesus was referring to the day he would give his life as the final sacrifice to bring us back to God. But when Jesus gave up his life the curtain in the temple that used to separate God from his people was torn right down the middle. In effect, God was no longer confined to a building. He is now always present with us. And he longs to live in us and be with us. After all, we are his creation.

I used to think that Jesus meant that we are supposed to be real with him while we are singing to him at church. But Jesus basically said that it’s not about where you worship God. It’s not even about singing songs to him at all. It’s whether or not you worship him Spirit to Spirit. It’s about letting him in. To allow Him into your mess; into each compartment. Could it be that we have created elaborate rituals and practices in places that really don’t matter much to God, and in fact, keep him separate from the other compartments in our lives?

In Alan Hirsch’s book The Forgotten Ways, he makes the following statement…

“If we take the advice of the current alternative worship movement, of which I am generally greatly appreciative, one of the tasks of the church in the postmodern context is to make “sacred spaces,” places filled with rich and fresh symbolism expressed by new forms of media, where people can reconnect with God in new ways. This all sounds right, but when this impulse is divorced, as it often is, from the overarching task of mission (being the church), then it simply becomes another way in which we separate the sacred from the secular. By setting up a place that we call “sacred” because of the lighting, the incense, and the religious feel, what are we thereby saying about the rest of life? Is it not sacred? We cannot escape the conclusion that by setting up so called sacred spaces we, by implication, make all else, “not-sacred,” thereby assigning a large aspect of life in a non-God, or secular area… our task is to make all aspects and dimensions of life sacred- family, work, play, conflict etc.- and not to limit the presence of God to spooky religious zones.”

Come to think of it, Jesus never proscribed a style of worship to be followed. He never even attended a “church service” as we know it. He simply said, follow me. In other words learn to live the way I do. Come to think of it, God never proscribed a worship service for Adam and Eve. He simply asked them to enjoy life that was dripping with God’s presence, and walk with him every step of the way.

Could it be that worship has less to do with singing songs in a “sacred” space than learning to submit to Jesus as Lord in every compartment in our lives as a path to be walked? Maybe God is trying to get us to take down the walls of our compartments and give him rule over every area of our lives? Maybe God is more concerned with our, actively, knowing him rather than meeting together to just, passively, learn about him. Maybe that’s what it really means to be a follower of Jesus. One and the same God over every compartment. The same relationship in every area. One kingdom. One Lord over all


____________________________



1. What is your first reaction to this?

2. Do you have compartments?

3. What does that mean for how we worship?

4. Does this mean that our idea of worship is unnecessary or even wrong?

5. Are we asking people to attend something that isn’t as important as we think it should be?

6. What does this mean for you in “the real world?”



5 comments:

gdcbass said...

Good article. Comments to come.

gdcbass said...

I am absolutely compartmentalized, and it has always troubled me. It seems to just happen naturally, but has also become the standard in our society and politics, the separation of church and state principle, which has continued to be expanded to more and more aspects of life than were intended by the founding fathers. This has put Christians on the defensive (although we have often done much to give ourselves the black eye), and leaves us only the ability to
conduct our lives in a christian manner (which is good) but makes us uneasy to be open about it and share it.

Is our worship unnecesssary? No.
Wrong? No.
Less important? Maybe.

That we worship God in spirit and truth is key, and this can be done anywhere, at anytime, by anyone.

Is there a need for some form of corporate worship? Perhaps the most important aspect of corporate worship is coming together to sustain one another, to know that we are part of the larger body of Christ. And sometimes powerful things can happen when we come together, with the help of God, that couldn't happen otherwise.

One question in the article that I disagree with is "maybe God is more concerned with our getting to know him than meeting together to learn about him". I think learning about God IS getting to know him. And by coming together to share ideas and experiences, studying the Bible and praying together, we can come to know God in greater depth and richness than we might be able to do on our own.


Grant

Mike said...

"maybe God is more concerned with our getting to know him than meeting together to learn about him".

Do you think sometimes we attend worship more as spectators instead of active participants?

DM said...

I enjoyed this - very thought provoking.

I learned many years ago how God wanted to be involved with all of my life, not just Sunday, not just when I pray every morning, not just when I read the Word. Being a disciple of Christ is a 24/7 deal. Is it easy? No. Am I always successful? No.

So, I relate to and agree with some of the same feelings as Grant wrote about.

But the new thought for me with this article is addressing the place and priority of organized/planned worship services in the Church, and maybe more specifically at POP. At times it actually seems a subtle distraction from carrying out the mission of the Church.

I’ve always struggled with “bringing a friend to worship” in the sense of evangelism. Why would a non-believer want to come and worship?! So, in fact, non-worship church community events are the better venue, especially to build relationships and community. But events (be they worship, service, or social) in themselves don’t tell others about Jesus, we do. We do through our actions yes, but the words have to come at some point because actions can be misinterpreted or simply not understood. Don’t get me wrong, I know God calls us to serve, and that is an expression of His love through us. But there seems to be this wall between serving and discipling. And I think it’s because discipling often means going to a deeper level.

So what was my new thought? Well, that POP should focus less on having “inviting energetic worship services” and more on inviting and energetically making disciples. Note that the POP mission statement says nothing specifically about worship services.

The challenge for me (and I suspect some others) is to love God more in every part of my life so as to see how God wants me to love others. I know there are those people right in front of me who’s faith may need encouragement, and others whose “faith” is in “other gods.” Will I make the sacrifice of my time and therefore some of my own agendas to build relationships and start conversations about Jesus? Will I trust God enough to overcome my fears? Will I seek to worship the LORD by making disciples?

Yes, with the help of God. Amen.


Dale

Dox Rock said...

You're writing these aren't you?

Of course, you are right to say that if we "are" the church then worship is less about a "sacred space" than about "being" the church.

Interesting thought...if one space or one type of activity (missionary or pastoral leader)is "sacred" then is everything else in life not?
I suppose it depends on your perspective. "Blessed are the feet of those that bring the gospel" I am jealous of those people in OMNI who have carried Christ across the world, but I truly believe that my mission field is with my family now and my task is sacred.

I also struggle with the "sacred/secular" artificial divisions I see from my fundamentalist Christian patients. I have parents that refuse vaccines or necesssary medical care at times due to "religious beliefs". If they believe that "all good things come from the Father" how can they deny the knowledge that devised these advances? Does God even need to work just through "christians"? Why, even the "very stones would cry out" his praise.

But now time for true confessions. Talk about neat freaks...every MD has to be a little OCD (am I right, Grant?)
Hate salisbury steak...but love the little compartments. OK...so my jewelry is sorted in to flat fishing tackle boxes with dozens of compartments, so I can see everything at a glance.

Speaking of compartments...the OT says that God is a jealous God. Well, I am a jealous worshipper. I hate to admit this, but I am often happier when I can worship in church without the distraction of my children. My husband is more of a "be" the church kind of guy and gave up on organized religion decades ago, so I don't even want to bring him...more compartments.

Finally, I must take exception to the comment about worship and singing songs. The OT is full of references to singing praise and making a joyful noise... Kurt Vonnegut once said, "The only proof I need for the existence of God is music". Singing is my prayer..my direct line...my recharger, if you will. I'm a bad musician...I close my eyes...I miss breaks and changes...but I am
lost in my God (compartment?)